Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Which Is a Healthier Diet?

The Maggie Q Diet allows only plant-based, whole foods and focuses on lean physique, clear skin, and high energy. It is centered around vegetables, smoothies, juices, and plant proteins. While it is promoted as a diet for clean eating and longevity, it is high in carbohydrates and can cause inflammation. However, the Carnivore Diet is a zero-carb, animal-based diet that aims to improve health markers by eliminating unnecessary food. Let’s compare the two diets to find out which one is actually a healthier diet.

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Which Is a Healthier Diet?
Highlights

Who Is Maggie Q, and What Is the Maggie Q Diet?

Margaret Denise Quigley, or Maggie Q, is an American actress, model, and wellness advocate, known for doing her own stunts, intense physical training, and staying incredibly fit well into her 40s.

Maggie Q is very open about her plant-based lifestyle and holistic approach to health. Over time, fans and media outlets started calling her eating and lifestyle the “Maggie Q Diet,” even though she has never sold it as a program.

Her philosophy is more “how I treat my body” than “eat this, not that.” Her diet is about eating plant-based/ vegan foods and avoiding processed foods, refined sugar, and dairy.

She focuses on whole foods, vegetables, legumes, healthy fats, and proper hydration, and eating for energy, inflammation control, and long-term health, not weight loss.

She has talked about how changing her diet helped her recover from chronic health issues she had in her 20s. Maggie Q Diet is not just about food but also lifestyle.

She practices yoga and functional training, manages stress, focuses on proper sleep and recovery, and tries to create a strong mind-body connection.

Learn More: Are Humans Carnivores? What Science Says about Eating Meat?

How Is A Day in Maggie Q Diet?

A typical day includes green juices or smoothies in the morning, a large high-vegetable lunch, light snacks such as fruit or nuts, and a lighter dinner including vegetables and plant proteins.

Maggie Q describes her diet as “plant-based” rather than strictly vegan, although she does not include many animal products in her routine.

Her diet includes high fiber and antioxidants, and reduces ultra-processed foods. However, the Maggie Q Diet is high in carbohydrates and low in complete proteins, as well as nutrients such as vitamin B12, bioavailable iron, zinc, DHA/EPA, and saturated fat, all of which play important roles in metabolism, brain health, and hormonal function.

While many believe that eating vegetables and fruits means a healthy diet. The important thing is your macronutrient balance.

Diets high in carbohydrates and low in protein and healthy fats can disrupt metabolism and cause inflammation, which is the root cause of various chronic diseases.

This is why many health specialists and dietitians have started focusing on low-carb, animal-based diets like Keto and Carnivore.

To find out which approach is healthier for the body, we need to compare them and check their pros and cons. Now that we know the basics about the Maggie Q Diet, let’s learn about a famous animal-based diet, the Carnivore Diet.

Learn More: Beef Fat on a Carnivore Diet: What Can You Use It For & How?

[cta-gocarnivore-plans]

What Is the Carnivore Diet?

The Carnivore Diet is a zero-carbohydrate, elimination diet that removes unnecessary or harmful plant-based foods and includes only foods derived from animals, such as

  • Beef, lamb, pork, poultry
  • Fish and seafood
  • Eggs
  • Organ meats
  • Animal fats (tallow, butter, ghee)

All plant foods are eliminated, including fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, and sugars. This is because plant-based foods contain anti-nutrients that can disrupt hormones and digestion and cause inflammation.

By reducing the intake of carbohydrates, based on your metabolic flexibility, your body shifts from burning carbohydrates (sugar/glucose) to burning fat (ketones) through a process called ketosis [1].

By removing carbohydrates and plant anti-nutrients, many people can reduce inflammation, balance hormones, help insulin sensitivity, improve digestion, and boost immune function.

Despite plant-based protein sources, animal-based foods provide complete proteins and highly bioavailable micronutrients in their most absorbable forms.

The Carnivore Diet is used as a therapeutic elimination diet for autoimmune disease, obesity, type 2 diabetes, IBS, and food sensitivities.

To be able to decide better between the Maggie Q Diet and the Carnivore Diet, let’s compare the features of these two diets and their effects on different health markers.

Learn More: David Goggins Diet: Food List and Meal Plan

[cta-meetings]

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Macronutrients

To easily compare the macronutrients we can gain from Maggie Q Diet and the Carnivore Diet, let’s take a look at the table below [2].

Learn More: Lactose Free Whey Protein on a Keto and Carnivore Diet

FeatureMaggie Q DietCarnivore Diet
Carbohydrates High to moderate Near zero
Protein Moderate High
Fat Low to moderate High
Fiber High Zero
Sugar intake Moderate (fruit, smoothies) Zero

The Maggie Q Diet provides most calories from carbohydrates. While this can support endurance activity, it can cause blood sugar fluctuations, hunger cycles, and cravings for some individuals.

The Carnivore Diet is built on fat and protein that stabilize blood glucose, help control appetite, and improve metabolic flexibility.

Many studies show that from a body-composition perspective, high-protein, low-carb diets work better than high-carb diets for fat loss and muscle retention.

If you are concerned about the lack of fiber on a Carnivore Diet, you should learn about the myths about fiber, which you can read in this article about Constipation on a Carnivore Diet: Causes and Remedies.

[cta-meal-plan]

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Micronutrient Density

In addition to macronutrients, we need to consider the amount of micronutrients we can get from each diet. The table below summarizes the main micronutrients found in Maggie Q Diet vs. the Carnivore Diet [3].

Learn More: Ray Peat Diet: Benefits, Downsides, & Points You Can’t Miss!

NutrientMaggie Q DietCarnivore Diet
Vitamin B12 Supplement required Naturally high
Iron Non-heme (lower absorption) Heme iron (high absorption)
Zinc Moderate High
Omega-3 DHA/EPA Minimal High
Vitamin A (retinol) Low High
Choline Low High

Plant-based diets rely heavily on fortified foods and supplements to prevent deficiencies. The Carnivore Diet supplies these nutrients in their most bioavailable forms, reducing dependence on supplementation [4] [5].

Learn More: The Mounjaro Diet: Side Effects, Meal Plan, and Food List

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Protein Quality and Muscle Support

Plant proteins in the Maggie Q Diet lack one or more essential amino acids and have lower digestibility scores. To meet daily protein needs, people usually need to combine foods carefully or use necessary supplements [6].

Animal proteins found in the Carnivore Diet contain all essential amino acids, are highly bioavailable, and provide leucine, the main trigger for muscle protein synthesis.

This makes the Carnivore Diet a much better choice for preserving lean muscle mass, especially during weight loss or aging.

Learn More: The Gary Brecka Diet: How to Follow The 30/30/30 Method?

[cta-shop-products]

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Digestion and Gut Health

The Maggie Q Diet focuses on consuming fiber to improve gut health. While fiber can help some people, it can worsen bloating, gas, and IBS symptoms in others. Plant-based diets like the Maggie Q Diet can also help prevent certain cancers [7] [8] [9].

The Carnivore Diet removes fermentable carbohydrates entirely, which can reduce bloating, gas, and bowel issues and improve gut barrier integrity.

Many individuals with Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, and IBS report dramatic symptom improvement on a Carnivore Diet [10].

Learn More: Joe Rogan's Carnivore Diet: Everything You Should Know

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Blood Sugar and Insulin Control

High-carbohydrate meals containing smoothies, fruit, and grains can spike blood glucose. Over time, this can lead to insulin resistance, which causes a wide range of chronic diseases [11].

However, the Carnivore Diet keeps insulin levels low and stable by eliminating carbohydrates, which can help you:

  • Burn fat
  • Lose weight
  • Improve insulin sensitivity
  • Lower triglycerides
  • Boost metabolic health

The Carnivore Diet can usually provide rapid and lasting improvements for people with prediabetes or type 2 diabetes [12].

Learn More: The Lipedema Diet: All You Need to Know

[cta-course-fatloss]

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Weight Loss

The Maggie Q Diet can lead to weight loss mainly through calorie reduction and increased food volume. However, hunger and plateaus are common.

The Carnivore Diet promotes weight loss through:

  • Appetite suppression
  • Increased satiety
  • Hormonal regulation
  • Ketosis

Most people experience faster and more sustainable fat loss on a Carnivore Diet without calorie counting [13].

Learn More: The No-Carb No-Sugar Diet: Everything You Need to Know

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Inflammation and Autoimmune Conditions

Plant foods contain natural defense chemicals, such as lectins, oxalates, and phytates, that can trigger inflammation in susceptible individuals [14].

The Carnivore Diet removes these compounds entirely, which is why many people with:

  • Rheumatoid arthritis
  • Psoriasis
  • Hashimoto’s
  • Eczema

report symptom reduction or remission.

Learn More: Babe Ruth's Diet: Why Should You Avoid It?

[cta-gocarnivore-plans]

Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet: Simplicity and Sustainability

The Maggie Q Diet needs meal prep, food combining, smoothie ingredients, and supplements, while the Carnivore Diet is very simple. You base the meals on meat and animal proteins + healthy animal fats.

The simpler your diet is, the easier it is to follow in the long-term.

Learn More: The Rina Diet: 90-Day Meal Plan for Weight Loss

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

One of the positive points that the followers of the Maggie Q Diet focus on is that it has minimal environmental impact and supports animal welfare.

However, followers of the Carnivore Diet believe that regenerative grazing systems show that properly managed livestock can improve soil health, sequester carbon, and support ecosystems.

Additionally, the Carnivore Diet requires fewer crop monocultures, pesticides, and transport chains.

Learn More: What Is Paul Saladino's Diet? All You Should Know

Who Benefits Most from Each Diet?

The Maggie Q Diet can be a good choice for ethically-concerned vegans, people who tolerate carbohydrates well, and those seeking light, low-fat eating.

The Carnivore Diet is better for boosting weight loss, mental clarity, and autoimmune function, reducing insulin resistance and digestive disorders, and building muscle mass.

[cta-meetings]

So, Which Is Better? Maggie Q Diet vs. Carnivore Diet

While the Maggie Q Diet emphasizes clean plant foods, it focuses heavily on carbohydrates and supplementation.

The Carnivore Diet can provide higher-protein quality, higher micronutrient density, better blood sugar control, reduced inflammation, and greater fat loss.

For most people seeking optimal health, body composition, and metabolic resilience, the Carnivore Diet clearly can be better than the Maggie Q Diet.

Having said that, you need to consult your healthcare provider first to ensure any diet you choose aligns with your health status, body needs, and fitness goals.

Learn More: A Zero-Carb Diet: All You Need to Know

FAQs

Here are answers to the most frequently asked questions about the Maggie Q Diet.

[cta-meal-plan]

Is Maggie Q vegan?

Maggie Q follows a mostly plant-based diet and avoids animal products, though she prefers the term “plant-based” rather than vegan.

What Does Maggie Q Typically Eat in a Day?

Green juices or smoothies, vegetables, fruits, salads, grains, nuts, and plant protein.

Learn More: Jordan Peterson’s Diet: What Is It and What Are Its Results?

Does the Carnivore Diet Cause Nutrient Deficiencies?

No, animal foods provide complete proteins and highly bioavailable vitamins and minerals.

Which Diet Is Better for Weight Loss?

The Carnivore Diet can lead to faster and more sustainable fat loss.

Can You Build Muscle on a Plant-Based Diet?

Yes, but it needs careful planning and supplementation. You can gain superior amino acids naturally on a Carnivore Diet.

Learn More: What Is an Animal Based Diet? Everything You Must Know

Is Fiber Necessary for Gut Health?

Not necessarily. Many people thrive without fiber and experience improved digestion. It can also cause digestive problems in sensitive individuals.

Is the Carnivore Diet Safe Long Term?

While more research needs to be done about the long-term effects of the Carnivore Diet, many individuals follow it for years with good biomarkers and symptom improvement.

Learn More: Long-Term and Short-Term Side Effects of The Carnivore Diet

Which Diet Is Better for Inflammation?

The Carnivore Diet generally reduces inflammation more effectively.

Similar Posts

Recent Recipes

Meet Rina | Founder Of The Primal

The Primal is your ultimate resource for the ketogenic diet—helping you lose weight, heal chronic disease, and take back your health, all for free!

Founded by Rina Ahluwalia, a health expert with 20+ years of experience and host of The Primal Podcast (on YouTube, Spotify & Apple Podcasts), we bring you weekly in depth conversations with board-certified doctors on topics like insulin resistance, cancer prevention, heart disease, and more.

Everything we share is backed by research and published on The Primal Lab, with references, books, tools, and easy-to-follow guides. Plus, you’ll find thousands of free articles, blog posts, recipes, and troubleshooting tips at ThePrimal.com to help you succeed on Carnivore and Keto.
👉 Subscribe to The Primal Podcast on YouTube or join our mailing list using the below form for the latest health insights—straight to your inbox!

Monthly Carnivore Challenges
Join