The Sugar Diet has emerged as a weight loss trend, and those on a high-sugar, low-fat diet believe it can help them shed pounds. Some even claim it can boost energy, improve metabolism, and even help with weight loss. But if this sounds too good to be true, that's because it is! Let’s break down what the Sugar Diet actually is, why it's scientifically flawed, and why low-carb approaches like the Carnivore Diet are smarter, healthier, and more sustainable choices.
Highlights
What Is the Sugar Diet?
The Sugar Diet isn’t a formal program with specific sets of rules. Some versions focus on high consumption of fruit, others focus on sugar-based snacks alongside a low-fat diet.
Generally, on a Sugar Diet, you should consume high-carb, low-fat foods, with sugar providing most of the daily energy.
Followers of the Sugar Diet claim that this can heal metabolism, enhance mood, and support weight loss by preventing fat storage.
It’s a diet that tells people to eat more sugar to lose weight. Sounds ridiculous? That’s because it is!
[cta-gocarnivore-plans]
Does the Sugar Diet Lead to Quick Weight Loss?
It may lead to weight loss, but at the expense of sugar addiction and insulin spikes, which are the main causes of various chronic illnesses.
The Sugar Diet might cause quick weight loss at first because of
Calorie Restriction: Some versions of the Sugar Diet are low in fat and protein, which can lower total calorie intake.
Water Loss: Consuming high-carb foods increases glycogen stores. Each gram of stored carbohydrate (glycogen) holds about 3 to 4 grams of water. So when you eat a high-sugar diet, you may quickly lose water. But it doesn’t mean you are losing fat; it is water that is lost. This short-term water loss is mistaken for real weight loss.
Temporary Metabolic Rise: Eating sugar can give a short-term energy boost and raise metabolic rate slightly, but it’s short-lived and is usually followed by crashes.
Join 100,000+ subscribers to get monthly emails on the best science-based tools and strategies for optimal health from Rina.
Thank you! You're now subscribed!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
We value your time and send just 1 insightful email monthly.
You'll also get Rina's exclusive Daily Blueprint. In it, Rina shares her daily routine. She also shares practical tools and protocols that you can use to heal inflammation and maximize your health.
By submitting your email to subscribe, you agree to The Primal's privacy policy
But these seemingly positive changes come with:
Muscle Loss Risk: When you focus on sugar and don’t eat enough fat and protein, your body may burn muscle instead of fat.
Hunger Spikes: Eating sugar increases insulin, which increases hunger and leads to overeating later.
Fat Gain Rebound: Most people regain weight, and more, due to blood sugar crashes and binge cycles.
Insulin Resistance Over Time: Eating sugar regularly promotes fat storage, not fat burning.
So, while a Sugar Diet can make the scale dip briefly, it usually leads to fat gain, metabolic damage, and energy crashes in the long run. Let’s see what research studies say about a Sugar Diet.
What Does Science Say about the Sugar Diet?
Different research studies show that the Sugar Diet is actually a stupid idea for weight loss or improving health for the following reasons.
Blood Sugar Spikes and Crashes
High-glycemic foods (like sugar, white bread, and processed carbs) cause a rapid rise in blood sugar, followed by a sharp insulin spike.
Insulin clears glucose from the blood quickly, sometimes dropping it too low. This crash triggers hunger signals, especially for more carbohydrates (sugar).
As a result, you feel hungry sooner and tend to eat more calories overall, fueling a cycle of overeating [1] [2].
These fluctuations in insulin and blood glucose levels can lead to mood swings, fatigue, and constant hunger.
High levels of insulin are also linked to various diseases, such as obesity, type 2 diabetes (T2D), hypertension, peripheral vascular disease, and coronary artery disease [3].
[cta-meetings]
Promoting Insulin Resistance
According to the American Diabetes Association, eating excessive sugar is a key factor in metabolic disorders [4].
Eating high-sugar foods regularly brings high levels of glucose to your bloodstream, forcing your body to release large amounts of insulin to manage it.
Over time, your cells become less responsive to insulin, which is an illness called insulin resistance [5].
As a result, your body needs to produce even more insulin to get the same effect, which increases fat storage, disrupts hormones, and raises the risk of type 2 diabetes [6].
Chronic high sugar intake is directly linked to insulin resistance, which is a precursor to type 2 diabetes, obesity, and heart disease [7].
Increasing Inflammation
Eating high-sugar foods can increase inflammation by raising blood glucose and insulin levels, which trigger the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines [8].
Over time, this constant immune response creates chronic low-grade inflammation in the body, causing issues like joint pain, heart disease, and even depression. Refined sugars can also increase oxidative stress, damaging cells and tissues [9] [10].
[cta-meal-plan]
Causing Sugar Addiction
Eating high-sugar foods can stimulate the brain’s reward system by releasing dopamine, the same feel-good chemical triggered by addictive substances [11].
Over time, this can create a cycle of craving, bingeing, and withdrawal, much like drug addiction. The more sugar you eat, the more you need to feel satisfied [12].
Mood swings, anxiety, and fatigue from blood sugar crashes.
Higher risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes, and heart disease.
Loss of control over eating habits, making it hard to stop even when you want to.
This addiction disrupts brain chemistry, leading to long-term physical and emotional health problems.
Nutrient Deficiency
A high-sugar diet like the Sugar Diet can lead to nutrient deficiency because sugary foods are calorie-rich but nutrient-poor [15].
Refined sugar provides zero essential nutrients. It displaces real, nutrient-dense foods from the diet, leading to deficiencies and weakened immune function [16].
When sugar replaces whole, nutrient-dense foods (like meat, eggs, or vegetables), your body misses out on essential vitamins, minerals, and proteins, which can result in:
Low levels of B vitamins, zinc, and magnesium
Weakened immune system
Poor energy production
Slower wound healing and muscle recovery
Fatigue, hair loss, and mood issues
In fact, sugar fills you up with empty calories while starving your body of what it truly needs.
Dr Berry’s Ideas on the Sugar Diet
Dr. Ken Berry released the following video to emphasize how absurd and harmful the Sugar Diet truly is.
Here are the highlights of his video:
Sugar Diet = Standard American Diet (But With Branding)
Dr. Berry points out that the Sugar Diet is nothing more than the Standard American Diet (SAD) repackaged, high in sugar, low in fat, and moderate in protein.
It's the same pattern that has already led to uncontrolled obesity and metabolic disease throughout the world, especially in the US.
[cta-shop-products]
Fructose: Natural but More Harmful Than Glucose
Dr Berry emphasizes how fructose, though natural in fruits and juices, is seven times more damaging to tissues than glucose due to its higher glycation potential. This damage doesn’t even show up in A1C tests.
Sugar Glycation Destroys Cells, But Who Cares, Right?
Sarcastically, Dr. Berry explains that sugar gums up cells and tissues, impairing function. But sugar diet promoters ignore this, focusing only on superficial, short-term weight loss.
Nobody Recommends the Sugar Diet—Except the Internet
If the Sugar Diet were so miraculous, Dr. Berry asks, where are the doctors and researchers promoting it? The answer: there are none.
It’s a trend with zero clinical backing, just a recycled version of the dietary pattern that made us sick in the first place.
No Human Culture Ever Thrived on a High-Sugar, Low-Fat Diet
Dr. Berry notes that no successful civilization in human history has eaten the way the Sugar Diet suggests. On the contrary, ancient and modern health collapses have stemmed from diets high in sugar and low in fat.
So, we come to realize that it is not surprising that our ancestors were mainly meat eaters, who focused on high-fat, high-protein, and low-carbohydrate sources.
Why Low-Carb and Carnivore Diets Work Better
Despite the problems that high-sugar diets cause for our insulin levels, low-carb, high-fat diets like Carnivore do not cause such spikes, which leads to significant health benefits.
Low-carb diets do not cause sugar highs and crashes because they provide steady energy through burning fats and proteins, not carbohydrates [17].
Fats provide slow, steady energy that supports mental clarity and physical endurance. Proteins help regulate blood sugar by slowing digestion and reducing post-meal glucose spikes [18].
This results in sustained energy levels throughout the day without the afternoon slump or constant snacking [19].
Reversing Insulin Resistance
Reducing the consumption of carbohydrates can restore insulin sensitivity in overweight and diabetic individuals [20].
Insulin resistance occurs when the body stops responding effectively to insulin, usually due to chronically high sugar and carbohydrate intake.
By reducing carbohydrates, especially refined sugars and starches, low-carb diets lower blood glucose and insulin levels [21].
This gives insulin receptors a chance to reset and become more sensitive again. Clinical trials have shown that low-carb diets can even reverse type 2 diabetes in many cases [22].
[cta-gocarnivore-plans]
Anti-Inflammatory Effects
Chronic inflammation is linked to nearly every modern disease, from heart disease to depression.
High-carb and high-sugar diets can worsen inflammation by promoting oxidative stress and feeding gut dysbiosis. In contrast, Low-carb diets like Carnivore and Keto reduce markers of inflammation and oxidative stress, like CRP (C-reactive protein) and IL-6 [23].
Animal-based diets like Carnivore also remove common irritants like seed oils, gluten, and processed carbohydrates, calming the immune system [24].
Nutrient-Dense Foods
Low-carb diets focus on whole, nutritious animal foods, like liver, eggs, red meat, and fatty fish, which are rich in bioavailable vitamins and minerals that your body can easily absorb and use. For example [25] [26]:
B12 supports nerve function and red blood cell formation.
Iron helps transport oxygen.
Zinc boosts immunity and hormone production.
Omega-3s reduce inflammation and support brain health.
The important point is that these nutrients are far more difficult to obtain in sufficient amounts on a high-sugar or plant-heavy diet.
High-sugar diets create a cycle of cravings, mood swings, and emotional eating. But low-carb diets break that cycle by stabilizing blood sugar and regulating hunger hormones like ghrelin and leptin [27].
People report improved focus, fewer food obsessions, better emotional control, and even relief from anxiety and depression. Without constant cravings, it’s easier to stick to healthy eating habits long term [28].
One of the lowest-carb diets that can provide these health benefits is the Carnivore Diet.
Carnivore: The Ultimate Low-Carb Solution
The Carnivore Diet, the third and last stage of the Primal Diet, is a zero-carb, animal-based, no sugar diet that emphasizes simplicity and nutrient density.
It eliminates plant toxins, allergens, and sugar, allowing the body to heal from chronic inflammation and metabolic dysfunction.
You can join the Go Carnivore Community to learn more about this diet and how it can help you maximize your health by avoiding unnecessary foods and mindful eating.
Despite what social media may show, the Sugar Diet is an unscientific trend that seems magical but fails to deliver real health benefits.
It promotes addiction, hormonal dysfunction, and nutrient deficiencies. In contrast, low-carb diets like Carnivore align with human biology, provide essential nutrients, and support stable energy, hormonal balance, and sustainable fat loss.
Anyhow, it is wise to consult a healthcare professional before changing your diet and starting a new eating approach.
Every week your favorite Carnivore doctors like Dr Chaffee, Dr Baker, Dr Bright join us LIVE to answer your medical questions and our coaches will help you lose weight and heal inflammation fast.
The Primal is your ultimate resource for the ketogenic diet—helping you lose weight, heal chronic disease, and take back your health, all for free!
Founded by Rina Ahluwalia, a health expert with 20+ years of experience and host of The Primal Podcast (on YouTube, Spotify & Apple Podcasts), we bring you weekly in depth conversations with board-certified doctors on topics like insulin resistance, cancer prevention, heart disease, and more.
Everything we share is backed by research and published on The Primal Lab, with references, books, tools, and easy-to-follow guides. Plus, you’ll find thousands of free articles, blog posts, recipes, and troubleshooting tips at ThePrimal.com to help you succeed on Carnivore and Keto. 👉 Subscribe to The Primal Podcast on YouTube or join our mailing list using the below form for the latest health insights—straight to your inbox!
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
